What is the gospel?
What elements must be present in order for the gospel to have been faithfully preached?
These questions came to my mind after hearing several pastors preach, with one in particular having the great duty of explaining what the gospel was. In hearing them, something struck me: we so easily assume the particulars of the gospel, especially if the audience is composed of church-goers. It is not as though any of these pastors (or those to whom this applies) intentionally leave out certain truths. Neither are they ignorant of the fundamental propositions inherent to the gospel. Rather, it is a subtle yet dangerous overemphasis on one aspect of God's work of salvation in and through Jesus Christ to either the exclusion or emaciation of the others. The reasons for this are great and many and I will not presume to know why a particular pastor is guilty of this homiletical fallacy. Instead, I want to point out, hopefully with humility and respect, the problem and as a response, offer a specific yet practical solution.
The Problem of Assumption
Assumption, in and of itself, is not a bad thing. In fact, it is good and proper to assume certain things as a Christian. We should assume that those who profess faith in Christ are Christians, unless their actions or beliefs prove otherwise. We should assume that our pastors are working for our good and are seeking to build up the church in maturity, unless their actions or beliefs prove otherwise, etc. However, it is rarely good to assume that Christians, let alone church-goers, are intimately or even vaguely familiar with the message and heart of the gospel. Not only is this, in all probability, a false assumption, but the very nature of man precludes it. We, as fallen sinners, are "naturally" opposed to the concept of grace. We forget it, deny it and try to live our lives ignoring it. It is contrary to our thinking, not to mention the concepts of sin, judgement and righteousness. Sin always leads us away from the gospel and towards a works-based righteousness. We will never drift into truth. We will never drift into righteousness. Christians need the gospel as much as unbelievers. To deny them of the clear articulation and application of it is to rob their souls of life.
So how is it assumed? More often than not, a pastor will take for granted the fundamental elements of the gospel. Sometimes the term is just used without any explanation. "Believe the gospel. It is the gospel that saves us, for it is the power of God for salvation to all who believe." At other times, Jesus' death and the forgiveness of sins offered in it are the sole propositions set forth. "Jesus died on the cross so that all who believe in Him might be forgiven of their sins. He paid the penalty of sin so that we wouldn't have to. He took what we deserved so that we might receive what he alone merited." All of these things are good and true, but they are not the gospel.
To the first I would ask, what is this gospel? Is it my experience at church? Is it what I try to live every day? What does it mean to believe? What do I need saving from, A bad marriage? An illness? A bad hair day?
To the second, Who is Jesus? What does a cross and death have to do with sin? If he is dead, how can he help me now? etc.
These are the assumptions that we are making with our gospel proclamation. We are assuming that people remember each of the elements of Christ's life, death and resurrection and what they accomplished. We are assuming that they understand the concepts of both God's love and justice, faith and repentance, sin and eternal life.
Depending on the topic of the sermon, one or more of the following tenets will usually be missing:
- sin, guilt, condemnation and judgment
- Christ's incarnation, life, death, burial, resurrection and ascension
- substitutionary atonement, sufficiency of Christ's work and forgiveness
- God's grace, love, righteousness and justice displayed at the cross
- command of repentance and faith.
While this may sound like a lot to cover, it can easily be delivered in under 5 minutes. If the heart of Christianity is to be found in the message of the gospel, shouldn't we be striving to teach it faithfully rather than assuming it is already understood?
The Problem of Emphasis
Not only is assumption a danger but so is its partner in crime: emphasis. Let us say, for the sake of discussion, that the pastor doesn't assume anything about his hearers. Instead, during the course of his sermon, he gets to the work and person of Jesus Christ and lays it out in detail. Well, if he isn't assuming anything, won't he be fine? Not necessarily. It has been my experience that the main message of the days sermon inadvertently leads to an unbalanced presentation of the gospel. If 1 Corinthians 12 has been expounded, the love of God towards sinners will receive the majority, if not all, of the emphasis. If Romans 2 has been exposited, the wrath and judgment of God towards sin will be the focal point - with grace and forgiveness taking a backseat. This is only a natural thing for us to do. We are excited and passionate about the subject we are expounding and as a result, we overemphasize that same part of the gospel. However, this is a very dangerous habit.
The gospel cannot be reduced to a single emphasis. It is not
merely a message of love or grace, etc. It is not
merely the death of Christ or the subsequent resurrection. Rather, it is
all of this and more, in their proper balance.
A Proposed Solution
So how can these things be prevented? I propose the following solution.
A. Get the content of the message nailed.
First and foremost, memorize the gospel message. I do not mean that you have a canned response that you present at every occasion. Instead, resolve in your mind to be able to recite the primary elements of the gospel so that if any of them are missing, you can quickly remedy the problem. So what are these primary tenets?
1)
Prolegomena: teach the law. While this is not the gospel message itself, it is necessary to be taught first in order for the gospel to be proclaimed in its proper context. Teach who God is (especially His righteousness and holiness) and what He demands (perfect keeping of His law). Explain sin and how every single person without exception is under the judgement and condemnation of God on account of it. (death, hell, etc.)
2)
The Message: it is
all about Christ. Explicate clearly his sonship, sinlessness and perfect obedience to the law and how He is the fullfillment of the Old Testament scriptures. Preach his death, why it was necessary and what it accomplished. (wrath and justice of God, sufficient atonement for and forgiveness of sin, reconciliation, peace, etc.) Last,
but certainly not least, explain the resurrection and ascension of Christ. (justification, victory over sin and death, acceptance of God, rule and reign in the heavens and the earth, etc.) The amount of detail you relay is entirely up to your discretion, but the
central elements of his life, death, burial and resurrection must be given their due.
3)
The heart: justification by grace through faith in Christ alone. Be sure to emphasize (see, I told you it was ok in and of itself) that this salvation is a free, unmerited gift of grace on account of the Father's love for sinners. It is not a reward for our works but a reward for Christ's. Justification is wholly and fully of grace
through faith. We are not justified by faith, but by means of our faith as a result of Christ's work. It is the great and glorious truth that God declares guilty sinners to be innocent in His sight on account of both the imputed righteousness of Christ and His full payment for our sins.
B. Present a balanced command as the proper response
4)
The response: Repentance and Faith. This message of what God has done in Christ is received by repentance and faith. It is not earned by them, but these are the first fruits of a redeemed heart. It is not enough to simply believe that Jesus died for sin and was resurrected for justification, for even the demons believe this. Faith must be explained as an assent to truth, personal acceptance of fact, and complete assurance in its object. Secondly, repentance is the companion of faith. If one believes without having a conviction of sin and subsequent turning away from it and to Christ for forgiveness, his faith is in vain. True faith is accompanied by true repentance.
5)
A Command: Yes, faith and repentance are a command from God, not a suggestion. Peter declared that God now commands all men everywhere to repent and believe the gospel. It is the duty of every man to do so, not merely a proposition they should consider. Keeping this in mind prevents us from "selling" the gospel. Rather than appealing to the emotions and sentimentalities of sinners, repentance and faith can be declared with full assurance that the Lord will save His people.
C. Take Heed to the Balance
We must make every effort to examine our speech so as to ensure that we are not neglecting any of these great truths of the gospel. Do not let the sermon's message of God's love trump his demonstration of justice and righteousness at the cross. All things in their proper place and in the proper time. Do not be careless and
assume you have it down. Constantly and persistently examine your messages to ensure you are preaching the whole counsel of God,
especially in the gospel.